Implementation differences

One method, implemented by several publishers, scored by VoLCA on the same database. Only the implementation varies, so where two disagree, the difference is theirs.

None of them is taken as the reference: a gap says two implementations differ, not which one is right. The same comparison can be made with pyvolca on any database and any two method collections you have loaded.

Engine version
volca 0.16.0 (73b86ac, v0.16.0, linux)
Measured on

BAFU 2026 v1, EF 3.1

The database BAFU 2026 v1, scored under each of these implementations of the method EF 3.1:

JRC
The reference package the European Commission's Joint Research Centre publishes, in ILCD format.
openLCA
The version openLCA ships in its LCIA methods package 2.8.2, where it is called “EF 3.1 Method (adapted)”.
ecoinvent
The implementation ecoinvent publishes beside ecoinvent 3.12, where it is called “EF v3.1”.
SimaPro 1.03
“Environmental Footprint 3.1 (adapted)” version 1.03, the method as SimaPro distributes it, its factors renamed to SimaPro's substance names.

Each number counts the indicators on which two implementations agree, their median ratio within 1 %. Open one to see the clouds.

Indicators on which two implementations agree
SimaPro 1.03ecoinventopenLCA
JRC 18/25 14/25 17/25
openLCA 22/25 16/25
ecoinvent 16/25