EcoSpold 1 ยท Calculation comparison

BAFU 2025 v2, POP into water

A comparison of published impact results with VoLCA calculations from the same source data and the same method, in the implementation named below. Points on the diagonal agree.

This page shows engine v0.17.0, which is not the newest measured. Compare the engine versions, or see the current comparisons.

Engine version
volca 0.17.0 (420b691, v0.17.0, linux)
Measured on
Comparison measurements and reference
DatabaseBAFU 2025 v2
Source formatEcoSpold 1
Impact method collectionEcological Scarcity 2021
Method implementationBAFU
Impact categoryPOP into water
UnitUBP
Activities compared11,547
Median ratio (VoLCA / published)1.0027
Comparison band1%
Activities outside the band2,739
Share outside the band23.72%
VerdictDisagrees, traced to the publisher's own results
Known reasonBAFU's workbook counts no "Benzene" emitted to unspecified water, which the method writes at 2.1e6 UBP/kg; on the residential sewer grid and the long-distance train, that benzene is the whole gap. BAFU 2026 counts it.
Points drawn2,095
Largest relative deviation-75.12%
Activity with largest deviationDrilling, deep borehole {CH}
Published referenceBAFU-2025 version2_LCIA Results.xlsx
BAFU 2025 v2, POP into water
Each point is one activity: what BAFU 2025 v2 published for POP into water (UBP), against what VoLCA computes from the same EcoSpold 1 source under the Ecological Scarcity 2021 factors of BAFU. The black line is equality and the grey band is 1%. 11,547 activities were compared; 2,739 fall outside the band, more than a picture can hold, so 1,925 of the 11,547 are drawn, evenly spaced over the published value whichever side of the band they fall, and the 170 of the 200 farthest from equality that this walk missed are added. Where several fall on one spot, at most three markers are drawn there, since a fourth would not darken it. Median ratio 1.0027, 23.72% outside the band. This misses the agreement a release is held to (at most 5% of activities outside the band and a median ratio inside it), for a known reason: BAFU's workbook counts no "Benzene" emitted to unspecified water, which the method writes at 2.1e6 UBP/kg; on the residential sewer grid and the long-distance train, that benzene is the whole gap. BAFU 2026 counts it.