VoLCA against published results

VoLCA is compared with results published by database producers, using the same source data and the same method, in the implementation each comparison names.

Every impact category a publisher's table holds for the method families measured here is shown, the ones that disagree included, each with the verdict a release is held to. What does not agree is on this page for the same reason as what does: so that anyone can see where the engine stands.

A disagreement is called known only once it has been traced flow by flow, on at least two activities, to the flows that make the gap. Its verdict says whose figures the gap comes from: the publisher's own results, when its table leaves out or counts differently a flow the method writes; the method's own data, when the method itself gives one flow two factors; or a rule VoLCA keeps on purpose, such as never lending a factor from one compartment to another. Open "Read the known reason" on a comparison for the flows and the activities. A disagreement nobody has traced stays a plain disagreement.

Engine version
volca 0.18.0 (85ea97a, v0.18.0, linux)
Measured on

393 drawn comparisons, 27 of which miss the agreement a release is held to. Every category a publisher's table holds is drawn, whether it agrees or not, and says which. Cells cover categories recorded across measured engines, within each database and collection. Gray cells distinguish recorded refusals from measurements not recorded. Colors identify databases only. The table counts each collection's verdicts; open a collection to see its comparisons.

ecoinvent

3.8 cut-off

IPCC 2013

ecoinvent 3.8 cut-off · ipcc-2013 · 4 agree

ecological scarcity 2013

ecoinvent 3.8 cut-off · ecological-scarcity-2013 · 18 agree, 1 disagree

ecoinvent

3.9.1 cut-off

EF v3.1

ecoinvent 3.9.1 cut-off · ef-v3.1 · 18 agree, 7 disagree

IPCC 2021

ecoinvent 3.9.1 cut-off · ipcc-2021 · 32 agree

ecoinvent

3.10 cut-off

EF v3.1

ecoinvent 3.10 cut-off · ef-v3.1 · 25 agree

IPCC 2021

ecoinvent 3.10 cut-off · ipcc-2021 · 32 agree

ecoinvent

3.10.1 cut-off

EF v3.1

ecoinvent 3.10.1 cut-off · ef-v3.1 · 25 agree

IPCC 2021

ecoinvent 3.10.1 cut-off · ipcc-2021 · 32 agree

ecoinvent

3.11 cut-off

EF v3.1

ecoinvent 3.11 cut-off · ef-v3.1 · 25 agree

IPCC 2021

ecoinvent 3.11 cut-off · ipcc-2021 · 16 agree

ecoinvent

3.12 cut-off

EF v3.1

ecoinvent 3.12 cut-off · ef-v3.1 · 25 agree

IPCC 2021

ecoinvent 3.12 cut-off · ipcc-2021 · 16 agree

Agribalyse

3.1.1

EF 3.1 adapted 1.0

Agribalyse 3.1.1 · ef31-adapted-1.0 · 1 agree, 16 not measured

Ozone depletion

Not measured in this run

Ionising radiation

Not measured in this run

Photochemical ozone formation

Not measured in this run

Particulate matter

Not measured in this run

Human toxicity, non-cancer

Not measured in this run

Human toxicity, cancer

Not measured in this run

Acidification

Not measured in this run

Eutrophication, freshwater

Not measured in this run

Eutrophication, marine

Not measured in this run

Eutrophication, terrestrial

Not measured in this run

Land use

Not measured in this run

Water use

Not measured in this run

Resource use, fossils

Not measured in this run

Resource use, minerals and metals

Not measured in this run

PEF

Not measured in this run

Ecotoxicity, freshwater

Not measured in this run

Agribalyse

3.2

EF 3.1 adapted 1.0

Agribalyse 3.2 · ef31-adapted-1.0 · 15 agree, 2 refused

PEF

Recorded refusal

Read refusal reason

ef31-adapted-1.0: no category of the method answers to this name

Ecotoxicity, freshwater

Recorded refusal

Read refusal reason

ef31-adapted-1.0: no category of the method answers to this name

BAFU

2025 v1

IPCC 2021

BAFU 2025 v1 · ipcc-2021 · 1 disagree for a known reason

GWP 100

BAFU 2025 v1, GWP 100

Disagrees, traced to the publisher's own results

2,018 outside the 1% band / 11,558 compared

Read the known reason

BAFU's workbook counts no "Methane, biogenic" emitted to air, which the method writes at 27 kg CO2-eq/kg; on Finnish reservoir hydropower that methane is the whole gap, 0.0387 where the workbook prints 0.000075. Version 2 of the same release counts it and agrees with us, on the same inventories.

Largest relative deviation: +51,475.55%

Ecological Scarcity 2021

BAFU 2025 v1 · ecological-scarcity-2021 · 17 agree, 2 disagree for a known reason, 2 refused

Heavy metals into air

BAFU 2025 v1, Heavy metals into air

Disagrees, traced to the publisher's own results

778 outside the 1% band / 11,556 compared

Read the known reason

BAFU's workbook counts no "Mercury II" emitted to air, which the method writes at 7.2e8 UBP/kg; on Lithuanian natural gas heat and Irish natural gas electricity, that mercury is the whole gap. Version 2 of the same release counts it.

Largest relative deviation: +55.07%

POP into water

BAFU 2025 v1, POP into water

Disagrees, traced to the publisher's own results

2,740 outside the 1% band / 11,547 compared

Read the known reason

BAFU's workbook counts no "Benzene" emitted to unspecified water, which the method writes at 2.1e6 UBP/kg; on the residential sewer grid and the long-distance train, that benzene is the whole gap. BAFU 2026 counts it.

Largest relative deviation: -75.12%

Biotic Resources

Recorded refusal

Read refusal reason

Ecological Scarcity 2021 (es2021-bafu): agrees, with nothing to draw: zero on both sides for all 11744 activities

Total

Recorded refusal

Read refusal reason

Ecological Scarcity 2021 (es2021-bafu): no category of the method answers to this name

BAFU

2025 v2

EF 3.1

BAFU 2025 v2 · ef-3.1 · 9 agree, 6 disagree, 1 disagree for a known reason

Water use

BAFU 2025 v2, Water use

Disagrees, traced to the publisher's own results

11,348 outside the 1% band / 11,536 compared

Read the known reason

BAFU's water column does not follow the inventories shipped with it. Net water is a remainder of withdrawals and returns about a thousand times larger, so slight inventory changes move it: computed on the shipped inventories it rises by a factor 1.68 from this release to 2026 v1, while BAFU's column stays put (median ratio 0.996). VoLCA on the 2026 v1 inventories lands at 1.016 of this column. 653 rows also repeat their climate change value, shifted by a power of ten.

Largest relative deviation: -100%

IPCC 2021

BAFU 2025 v2 · ipcc-2021 · 1 agree

Ecological Scarcity 2021

BAFU 2025 v2 · ecological-scarcity-2021 · 17 agree, 2 disagree for a known reason, 2 refused

POP into water

BAFU 2025 v2, POP into water

Disagrees, traced to the publisher's own results

2,739 outside the 1% band / 11,547 compared

Read the known reason

BAFU's workbook counts no "Benzene" emitted to unspecified water, which the method writes at 2.1e6 UBP/kg; on the residential sewer grid and the long-distance train, that benzene is the whole gap. BAFU 2026 counts it.

Largest relative deviation: -75.12%

Heavy metals into water

BAFU 2025 v2, Heavy metals into water

Disagrees, traced to the publisher's own results

828 outside the 1% band / 11,549 compared

Read the known reason

BAFU's workbook counts no "Cadmium" emitted to river nor "Iron, ion", both of which the method writes; on zinc-coated coils the river cadmium is the whole gap, on the capillary tube ceiling the iron. Version 1 of the same release counts the cadmium.

Largest relative deviation: +409.73%

Biotic Resources

Recorded refusal

Read refusal reason

Ecological Scarcity 2021 (es2021-bafu): agrees, with nothing to draw: zero on both sides for all 11744 activities

Total

Recorded refusal

Read refusal reason

Ecological Scarcity 2021 (es2021-bafu): no category of the method answers to this name

BAFU

2026 v1

EF 3.1

BAFU 2026 v1 · ef-3.1 · 18 agree, 7 disagree for a known reason

Ecotoxicity freshwater

BAFU 2026 v1, Ecotoxicity freshwater

Disagrees, traced to the method's own data and the publisher's own results

1,913 outside the 1% band / 11,682 compared

Read the known reason

The sum of its two sub-indicators' residues: the Chromium III line that carries the Chromium VI factor, and the hydrocarbons and acrylate BAFU leaves uncharacterised in river.

Largest relative deviation: +898.35%

Ecotoxicity freshwater (organics)

BAFU 2026 v1, Ecotoxicity freshwater (organics)

Disagrees, traced to the publisher's own results

2,947 outside the 1% band / 11,662 compared

Read the known reason

BAFU leaves "Hydrocarbons, unspecified" and "Acrylate" emitted to river uncharacterised; VoLCA reads them at the method's surface water factor. On polymethyl methacrylate sheet, the hydrocarbons are the whole gap.

Largest relative deviation: +2,442.78%

Human toxicity cancer (organics)

BAFU 2026 v1, Human toxicity cancer (organics)

Disagrees, traced to a rule VoLCA keeps on purpose

11,546 outside the 1% band / 11,654 compared

Read the known reason

The method gives methane a factor in this sub-indicator and not in the total; VoLCA applies it to BAFU's "Methane, fossil", which shares its CAS number, and BAFU does not. The total agrees.

Largest relative deviation: +241,382.16%

Land use

BAFU 2026 v1, Land use

Disagrees, traced to a rule VoLCA keeps on purpose

8,595 outside the 1% band / 11,661 compared

Read the known reason

BAFU files "Occupation, forest, unspecified" as an unspecified resource, where the method has no factor, and counts it at the method's land factor all the same; VoLCA borrows no factor across compartments.

Largest relative deviation: -100%

Resource use fossils

BAFU 2026 v1, Resource use fossils

Disagrees, traced to the publisher's own results

6,458 outside the 1% band / 11,651 compared

Read the known reason

BAFU counts its "Gas, natural/m3" at 36.0 MJ per m3, the method's factor for "Gas, natural"; VoLCA applies the method's own "Gas, natural/m3" factor, 34.5.

Largest relative deviation: +13.65%

Water use

BAFU 2026 v1, Water use

Disagrees, traced to the publisher's own results

5,807 outside the 1% band / 11,647 compared

Read the known reason

BAFU leaves "Water, fossil" uncharacterised, which the method counts like any other water taken: on Italian natural gas, the fossil water is the whole gap.

Largest relative deviation: +2,062.58%

IPCC 2021

BAFU 2026 v1 · ipcc-2021 · 1 agree

Ecological Scarcity 2021

BAFU 2026 v1 · ecological-scarcity-2021 · 19 agree, 2 refused

Biotic Resources

Recorded refusal

Read refusal reason

Ecological Scarcity 2021 (es2021-bafu): agrees, with nothing to draw: zero on both sides for all 11837 activities

Total

Recorded refusal

Read refusal reason

Ecological Scarcity 2021 (es2021-bafu): no category of the method answers to this name